As someone who took the diocesan RCIA path into the Catholic Church, I probably also have a different perspective on what Bp-Elect Lopes's possible path might be. I agree with two viewpoints I've heard from visitors now and then:
- The existing Anglican groups and parishes that could potentially move into an Ordinariate have already made their moves, with only a few exceptions.
- No matter how dissatisfied Episcopal rank and file may be with the actions of their national Church, they're largely satisfied with their local parishes and unwilling to open the Pandora's box involved in leaving the denomination -- the fate of the parishes that left the Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles in 2004 is a perfect example of the hazards implicit in that route.
But I don't think the growth will come from disaffected Anglicans. Frankly, as I sat in Christmas mass yesterday, I suddenly realized the priest was giving a homily to a nave filled almost entirely with adults, but he was talking down to us as though we were eight years old. (He started out by singing, "Happy Birthday, dear Jesus.")
I think there are enormous numbers of Catholics -- and if you insist, Catholics who haven't completed the sacraments of initiation -- who'd like to have a reverent mass without the guitar and tambourine and where they're addressed as adults. I think Ordinariates offer this opportunity. We'll have to see where Bp Lopes takes things.
Meantime, I need to find a new diocesan parish for the new year. I hope something can be done to keep St Mary of the Angels going so I can eventually get to mass there.